Hosted by OSOS , contributed by Di Martino on 15 May 2018
How can we promote choose of scientific careers for girls?
The starting point is a perception of S&T which confirms the current stereotypes, as with other large surveys, such as the Eurobarometer. In particular, the exact sciences are generally considered to be more difficult than human studies, as they would imply a special talent. On the other hand, technology involves a lot of sawing: being a hands-on activity, many students think that you need to be physically strong and that you get dirty, leading them to think that it is more a field for boys than for girls. Sciences and technology arouse spontaneous positive feelings amongst our participants.
We didn't find any conclusive differences between the two genders in terms of education choices and job opportunities. It is worrying that students do not seem to have a clear concept of the professions available. Their frame of reference is primarily the subjects they have at school and the experiments they perform there. In particular, participants call for a better knowledge of the S&T professions: all our participants told us of the importance of practice in S&T, and they see S&T as strongly linked with reality. In order to come closer to S&T, gaining experience with science and technology since an early age emerged to be very important.
Moreover, a change in stereotypes has to be carried out starting from teachers, role models, from the meetings with S&T professionals in schools, science centres, museums, and through the media, in fiction and advertising, by filming interviews with young and dynamic role models, both for boys and girls. Practically, a direct participation and a 'science and scientific careers in action' approach is desired as much as possible.
Based on a “philosophy of practice” the schools interested will develop a series of Pilot Activities (PA). The PA are implemented to integrate the learning process at school with practical activities that provide students with an insight about “what is behind a scientific career”, in terms of meaning, models and diversity of professions connected to science and technology. Therefore, the involvement of school teachers, students and professionals in S&T underlies all the activities.
The PA consist in activities which spur young people towards a scientific interdisciplinary view, more capable to meet the complexity of the contemporary world, explaining how science and technology are connected to their everyday life, and giving them a modern vision of science, on the one hand, while exploring the gender gap in science and technology professions.
The PA structure can be subdivide in two main steps:
The first one is a meeting (Open Space Technology workshop) with the scientist, parents, students , policy makers, etc… for to discuss directly with him /her about the topic of research and new application in the future for to understand the curricula necessary to arrive at same job. At the end of the OST you will have to choose the activities to be tested in the research centers involved
The second one is to do practical educational activities in the scientific lab of the research Institute involved.
As an example, in other project, the scientific and technological Institution involved have proposed many subject as new building materials; educational activities of basic physic, chemistry, nano electronics, seismic and volcanology, connecting to actuality studies and problems of real life.
The teachers and scientists will work together to define the models of the activities and structures of meeting, for to stimulate and to make curious the students, particularly girls to scientific and technological studies and relative careers.
The time necessary to do the PA described before is:
1 mouth for to organize the OST event.
1 day for the OST event.
2 mouth for to organize the program of PA (activities in the research labs) in collaboration with all research institutions involved;
3 mouths for to experimentation PA with world of research and classrooms involved.
1 mouth for to elaborate the final report.
In conclusion, it can be said that the results of the educational activities provided, in our opinion, an important contribution to the subject of women in science and in technology, by investigating among younger children the causes that determine their professional choices, proposing integrated actions among the world of school, the scientific community, and society in general.
So greater involvement of schools in training activities could provide a valid contribution to the changing of roles and of stereotypes that are still quite present in today's society and that influence future choices, especially for girls.
The result is the identification of new and viable methods to make science centres and schools work together, directly involving the world of research. The purpose of the PA proposed is to provide good ideas to bring two distant worlds, young people and science and technological careers, closer in a practical ways.
RRI principles
One of the key aspects of OSOS is the inclusion of RRI — Responsible Research and Innovation — principles (more information at RRI-Tools.eu).
This is how this Accelerator fits into the RRI model:
Governance |
The experts what will be involved can propose many subject as educational activities of basic physic, chemistry and new medicines, nano electronics, etc.. connecting to actuality studies and problems of real life. The teachers and scientists will work together to define the models of the activities and structures of meeting, for to stimulate and to make curious the students, particularly girls to scientific and technological studies and relative careers. |
Public Engagement |
The meetings with the scientists are necessary for to discuss directly with them about the topic of research and new application in the future for to understand the curricula necessary to arrive at same job. Then, awareness-raising became the central goal, to be achieved through concrete practices, to be participatory and appealing to students, particularly to girls. |
Gender equality |
The project explores gender differences when choosing a scientific career. The project approach consists of innovative methods of participatory research and a series of practical activities to overcome gender differences. Students will be able to contact the researchers and understand what to do to start a scientific career during the project. |
Science Education |
The disciplines of science and technology are often perceived as being difficult. Better educational methods are necessary to convince pupils, particularly girls, of the positive intrinsic value of science and technology and the jobs associated with this field. |
Ethics |
Students will share responsibility as they progress through the project, respecting the integrity of research and the social values of science. They will learn that everyone (male and female) has the same skills and must have the same opportunities in respect of gender differences. |
Open Access |
The purpose of this educational project is to provide good ideas to bring two distant worlds, young people and S&T careers, closer in a practical way. The reader shall have the task of adapting the activities to their interlocutors and of adjusting them to their needs. All materials should be shared open and free on the Internet in the school portal, that will be created, so that they can be re-used by other people interested in the topic. |
Feel
The real challenge of the proposed accelerator is to encourage students, especially girls, to study scientific and technological subjects and overcome the stereotype: women are not brought for scientific subjects but suitable for humanistic and "care" ", see the choices of biological sciences and medicine for academic studies and future work.
The starting point is a perception of S&T which confirms the current stereotypes, as with other large surveys. In particular, the exact sciences are generally considered to be more difficult than human studies, as they would imply a special talent. The organisation of the activities start with meetings between teachers and the researchers. The teachers emphasised the didactic value of practical activities in the laboratories on scientific and technological subjects connected to scientific and technological topicality, real life and work. Researchers also agreed on these remarks and they proposed activities on basic physics, nanotechnology, seismic risks, nanoelectronics, and the environment: quality of air, the composite materials, biochemistry, and volcanic risks, to be held in the university laboratories and in the research centres. The activity chosen was a practical activity in the research laboratories on scientific and technological subjects connected with scientific and technological topicality, real life and work.
The disciplines of science and technology are often perceived as being difficult. Better educational methods are necessary to convince pupils, particularly girls, of the positive intrinsic value of science and technology and the jobs associated with this field.
The Pilot Activies (PA) structure can be subdivide in three main steps:
- The first one is a blog on the web site of the project for to promote communication between students and scientists, centred on the professional and personal lives of scientists and the curiosity about subject of study proposed by researchers.
- The second one is practical educational activity in the scientific lab of the research Institute involved.
- The third one is a meeting with the scientist for to discuss directly with him /her about the topic of research and new application in the future for to understand the curricula necessary to arrive at same job.
The scientific and technological Institution involved have proposed many subject as new building materials; educational activities of basic physic, chemistry and new medicines, nano electronics, etc.. connecting to actuality studies and problems of real life.
The teachers and scientists will work together to define the models of the activities and structures of meeting, for to stimulate and to make curious the students, particularly girls to scientific and technological studies and relative careers.
In 2008 during the development of the GAPP project, from which this accelerator is proposed as a working model to follow, the following were involved 8 Scientific and technological Institutions:
- University Chemistry Department
- Institute of Cybernetic CNR Naples
- Institute National Geophysics and Volcanology - Vesuvius Observatory
- RISSC-LAB: Analysis and Monitoring of Environmental Risk
- University of Engineering
- INFN Institute National Nuclear Physic
- TRE Pool Activities with GIS Geographic(al) Information System
- University of mechanic Engineering
In total they were involved13 researchers, 8 females and 5 males (7 physicists, 1 chemist, 1 biologist, 2 geologists and 2 engineers); 14 teachers in field of mathematic, physic and science (5 men and 9 women); 10 high schools (4 Liceo specializing scientific studies; 1 Liceo specializing in foreign languages; 3 Technical Institutions; 2 Liceo pedagogical) with 17 classrooms and students from 14 to 18 year old.
An example of the time taken to plan the activities to be carried out:
December meeting with teachers and scientists
January organization of the PA calendar
February to April experimentation PAs
Imagine
Based on a “philosophy of practice” the schools interested will develop a series of Pilot Activities (PA). The PA are implemented to integrate the learning process at school with practical activities. On the basis of the need to make young people aware on what science and technology professions are, Pilot Activities were aimed at: connecting the schools with the world of the research; building a direct contact between researchers and students; new opportunities for students to understand scientific data processing in the business world. The core of the activities was a series of visits of the students involved in 9 laboratories, where the researchers have welcomed them, explained their activity, their everyday life, along with the understanding of specific scientific disciplines.
The main objectives of the Pilot Activities (PA) are:
1. to understand the loss of interest of young people, particularly girls, in science and technology studies and careers by exploring differences in their perception of S&T professionals, and raise awareness among experts and stakeholders on this issue;
2. to promote social dialogue among researchers, teachers, students, parents and other social actors to identify the main issues and expectations of these groups;
3. to develop and test a range of PA to help overcome gender differences and create a connection between secondary school students and science and technology.
We can say that, from the experience carried out in the first year of the project, many things can be done regarding the modification of the stereotypes and the social roles, starting from school, involving all social factors that in some way have a determining role on the training of young people, their parents and teachers. In particular, we refer to the modification of stereotyped behaviour, to the reduction of gender approach, to the greater involvement of the female gender in male roles either at school or at home, to the increase moreover of the contacts and the interaction with the external world, especially with the female gender exponents that occupy roles of responsibility, of management, etc. in various applied fields: the scientific, technological and social ones.
Greater involvement of school and family in training activities could therefore bring a valid contribution to the change of the roles and of the stereotypes of today's society, which are still quite present and which influence future choices, especially those of girls.
Across the six countries involved in this project, the starting point is a perception of S&T which confirms the current stereotypes, as with other large surveys, such as the Eurobarometer. In particular, the exact sciences are generally considered to be more difficult than human studies, as they would imply a special talent. On the other hand, technology involves a lot of sawing: being a hands-on activity, many students think that you need to be physically strong and that you get dirty, leading them to think that it is more a field for boys than for girls. Sciences and technology arouse spontaneous positive feelings amongst our participants.
We didn't find any conclusive differences between the two genders in terms of education choices and job opportunities. It is worrying that students do not seem to have a clear concept of the professions available. Their frame of reference is primarily the subjects they have at school and the experiments they perform there. In particular, participants call for a better knowledge of the S&T professions: all our participants told us of the importance of practice in S&T, and they see S&T as strongly linked with reality. In order to come closer to S&T, gaining experience with science and technology since an early age emerged to be very important.
Moreover, a change in stereotypes has to be carried out starting from teachers, role models, from the meetings with S&T professionals in schools, science centres, museums, and through the media, in fiction and advertising, by filming interviews with young and dynamic role models, both for boys and girls. Practically, a direct participation and a 'science and scientific careers in action' approach is desired as much as possible.
In conclusion, it can be said that the results of the project provided, in our opinion, an important contribution to the subject of women in science and in technology, by investigating among younger children the causes that determine their professional choices, proposing integrated actions among the world of school, the scientific community, and society in general, on a European level.
So greater involvement of schools in training activities could provide a valid contribution to the changing of roles and of stereotypes that are still quite present in today's society and that influence future choices, especially for girls.
http://gapp.sissa.it/Partners.aspx?section=34
http://www.scientix.eu/web/guest/projects/project-detail?articleId=52058
Create
This model is a two-year project meant to explore gender differences at the time of choosing a science careers. Innovative participatory research methods and a range of practical activities to overcome gender differences are the project focus. It is implementing through 4 steps of activities:
- Focus groups with young people, parents and teachers
- In depth interviews with scientists
- Open Space Technology workshops
- Pilot activities with school groups
The PA consist in activities which spur young people towards a scientific interdisciplinary view, more capable to meet the complexity of the contemporary world, explaining how science and technology are connected to their everyday life. The PA structure. The Pilot Activities consist in activities which spur young people towards a scientific interdisciplinary view, more capable to meet the complexity of the contemporary world, explaining how science and technology are connected to their everyday life, and giving them a modern vision of science, on the one hand, while exploring the gender gap in science and technology professions. The result starts from the scientific interests of young people for developing hands-on activities, workshops, visits, laboratory activities in different institutions, in order to create a connection between what they studied and the real world. Each pilot activity features an active meeting of young people with researchers in the field of S&T.