Skip to main content

DARK SKIES RANGERS - How can schools fight light pollution?

Hosted by OSOS , contributed by nuclio on 10 May 2018

General description

The international project and accelerator Dark Skies Rangers (DSR) aims to create a network of OSOS schools that will combat the problem of light pollution, by raising awareness among the educational community and local authorities to change lighting systems and preserve the night sky.
Our planet, when seen from above during night time, exhibits a large number of lit areas. For example, we can easily identify the areas of greater population density in Iberian Peninsula when it is seen from the International Space Station during night time (see figure bellow). Those light patches also identify areas of great light pollution.

Iberian Peninsula as seen from space (source: NASA).

Iberian Peninsula as seen from space (source: NASA).

Light pollution is caused by outdoor lighting that light up upwards and/or sideways, making the night sky brighter, wasting energy and money, contributing to climate change, affecting wildlife, ecosystems and people’s quality of life, and preventing astronomical observations.

This accelerator focus on the problematic of light pollution, fighting bad quality outdoor lighting and wasting of energy, decreasing public costs with lighting, while at the same time promoting an increase on the quality of life both for humans and the wildlife, increasing the security on the local communities and give the night sky back to the populations. These goals will allow to increase the attention to science by both students and local community, to stimulate teachers to adopt innovative teaching practices based on Inquiry-based learning (IBL)  which have been proven to be highly effective in science education (see here and here, for example) – to generate and increase civic awareness, and to stimulate a proactive and responsible participation in the decisions of the community. DSR will, therefore, promote the enrichment and renewal of the science curriculum and others subjects, such as civic classes and philosophy.

Addressed challenge

You can start introducing the problem under question to your students by presenting night time images of places where light pollution is identifiable, such as images of the Earth as seen from space, photos of your city (or a nearby one). If appropriate, photographs of the school taken during the night can also be presented, highlighting the public illumination. When students start to understand what is light pollution and how artificial light is commonly misused, you can propose them to create teams to address this problematic in their region and try to find solutions for it.

In this activity, students will naturally interact with different stakeholders, such as their families, local policy makers (local government, municipality, departments responsible for public lighting, energy companies, etc.), experts in lighting systems (researchers from nearby universities or research institutes), companies producing lighting technologies, and local communities, just to name a few. Like so, students will have the opportunity to get awareness about the problematic of light pollution, to learn directly with experts about lighting systems (both indoor and outdoor), and to discuss and propose strategies to policy makers in order to improve the public illumination in their region.

The conclusions of the projects will then be presented to the school community and all stakeholders involved in the activity (family, local community, experts, municipality). We suggest that the local administration be invited to a public session, where students will present the solutions and will invite decision makers to implement them. It is natural that several projects and corresponding solutions will be developed in the framework of the this activity (one per team/group).

In short, in this activity we propose:

  • To raise awareness among the students to the theme of light pollution;
  • To motivate students to investigate about light pollution using all resources available (Internet, consulting experts on the matter, etc.);
  • To let them develop research projects and find solutions for the problems they will identify;
  • To present their strategies to tackle the identified problems to all stakeholders.

Learning objectives

  • Realise that the night sky is not always accessible for observations even when there are no clouds;

  • Understand the concepts of intensity of light and light pollution;

  • Realise that most of the outdoor lighting systems are not properly designed, producing bad lighting;

  • Understand the concept of acceptable and unacceptable outdoor lighting;

  • Understand the impact of outdoor lighting on energy resources, on public costs and on the local and national economy, on security, on the quality of living of people and wildlife, and on astronomical observations;

  • Investigate alternative outdoor lighting systems;

  • Development of 21st century skills, such as collaboration, communication, critical thinking and problem solving, creativity, tolerance, and global citizenship awareness;

The whole process will be student centred, with the integration of a STEAM approach.

RRI principles

One of the key aspects of OSOS is the inclusion of Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) principles (more information at RRI-Tools.eu). This is how this Accelerator fits into the RRI model:

RRI principles
Governance

Students will share information and results with stakeholders, establishing a lasting, two-way relationship with the aim of ensuring better project results.

That is, students will research about good quality lighting, and then will investigate how is illumination done in the environments they use on a daily basis, whether they are private or public. By exchanging information with stakeholders in their ommunity at various stages, such as local government and experts (chairman of the parish council, councillors, architects, researchers, just to name a few), they will debate with them on how to proceed in the project, tackle the issues they found, and thus improve the illumination of the place where they live.

Public engagement

Students will be able to improve the lighting of several places. Doing so, they can involve different stakeholders in each of the phases of the project - such as their parents/guardians, local government, research institutes, and others - in a partnership aiming at finding innovative solutions for the problems addressed by this accelerator.

That is, parents/guardians will help their children to investigate the public lighting of their neighborhoods, local experts can give guidance, support and feedback to students during their research, and local government can evaluate the progress made by students throughout the project.

Gender equality

Students can work in gender-balanced teams when carrying out their research, and will be able to contact female stakeholders with a scientific career during the project.

That is, experts involved can be both men and women, in order to show the female perspective of the scientific profession. Female models in science can be a reference for students.

Science Education

Science will be used in this activity to solve real problems affecting the community, by improving the illumination of both public and private spaces, and therefore contribute positively to the community as a whole. This can help students become better citizens with the help of science.

That is, science subjects, such as physics and mathematics, are used by students to learn about the types of lights, compare them, perform measurements, and to propose effective solutions to improve the lighting environment, according to the space, location, and its specifications.

Ethics

Students will reflect on the impacts of our actions as a society on the planet. They will share responsibility while moving forward with the project, in compliance with the research integrity and the social values of science.

That is, students will promote the installation or the improvement of the illumination of public and private spaces through a scientific process, so that the community will benefit directly from the impact of the project. They will reflect on the environmental and societal impact of their project, and they will use what they have learnt to disseminate the need to improve the lighting of areas occupied by humankind (specially urban areas), including both private and public spaces.

Open Access

All materials will be shared open and freely on the Internet, so that they can be re-used by other people interested in the topic. Students can also use social media and/or other content platforms to disseminate their findings.

That is, students can use or develop online platforms for the project, such as their own blog, where they can share publicly, openly, and freely their resources, materials, progress, and results.

Available partnerships opportunities

General citizen-scientist

  • Identify some constellations and their stars, measure the apparent brightnesses of the latter and compare them to reference values;
  • Identify examples of good and bad outdoor lighting, measuring the illuminance of the neighbourhood and of special spots;
  • Get appointments with policy makers (members of local government, etc.);
  • Analyse the impact of light pollution in the local flora and fauna;
  • Awareness about outdoor and indoor illumination malpractices.

Parents

  • Assist their children in the outdoor activities;
  • Assist their children in getting meetings with policy makers and other relevant stakeholders;
  • Participate in the Science Café sessions organised by their children and teacher.

Teachers

  • Provide students with the necessary background and information, and help them preparing and mastering  the tool snecessary to carry out the outdoor activities;
  • Guide students preparing the interviews with policy makers and other stakeholders;
  • Guide students to organise Science Café sessions and exhibitions.

Industry

  • Develop and advertise more efficient outdoor lighting systems;
  • Create awareness of the impact of existing malpractices.
It is expected the teacher and the school to adapt this activity according to the characteristics of the milieu.

Author

Nuno Gomes
nuno.gomes@nuclio.pt
2017/2018
dsr logonuclio logo

Learning Objectives
Intensity of light; Light pollution; Designing of outdoor lighting systems; Impact of outdoor lighting; Raise awareness for electricity consumption; Develop real solutions for problems.

Description

During the Feel phase, the teacher will introduce students to the problematic of light pollution. Students will learn concepts related to the topic, and will organise individual or group field visits to places they will identify as potential sources of light pollution. They will also learn about the magnitude system used in Astronomy to measure the apparent brightness of celestial bodies and will use Stellarium to help them to characterise the level of light pollution in their surroundings.

This phase includes four sessions of 50 minutes estimated time each. For all sections, teacher should not give immediate answers, but allow students to research for the topics in question, encouraging them to share and discuss their findings with their colleagues, promoting debate in the classroom.

Resources needed

  • Computers with access to the Internet;

  • Pencil and paper to write on;

  • Star charts;

  • Internet resources: Globe at NightODS portal;

  • Luxmeter (optional).

Location

  • In the classroom;

  • In the surroundings of the school and of students' houses (streets, side walks, public gardens, parks, sport fields, etc.).

Session 1

Estimated time: 50 minutes.

  • Teacher awakes the curiosity of students for the theme of light pollution, presenting them images of places with and without light pollution (Earth seen from above during night, neighbourhoods, cities, night sky, etc.). Examples: https://youtu.be/8dc58ZrOuckwww.lightpollutionmap.info.
  • Teacher introduces the concept of light pollution and invites students to search for its impact in our lives: wasting of energy, increasing of public costs with lighting, quality of life for both humans and wildlife, security, and observation of the night sky.

The Light Pollution Map (www.lightpollutionmap.info).

The Light Pollution Map (www.lightpollutionmap.info).

Session 2

Estimated time: 50 minutes.

  • Students search and learn about different types of light, bulbs, lamps and luminaires;
  • Students search and learn about proper and improper ways to light the path in the streets;
  • Students search and learn about the colour of light and its importance for proper lighting;
  • Students search and learn about proper and improper ways to illuminate indoor spaces, such as libraries, schools, and different types of rooms in the house.

Schematics of “bad” and

Schematics of “bad” and "good" street lights. From left to right, in the first two examples, due to the spherical shape of the lamp without any reflector, or due to a bad design of the latter, light is sent upwards, originating light pollution; in the third and fourth cases, lamps include a reflector on top of them, preventing light to go upwards, making them energetically more efficient, thus causing less light pollution. The level of light pollution is represented by the number of stars seen by naked eye above the luminaires.

Session 3

Estimated time: 50 minutes.

  • Students must inspect street lights on their way home and around their neighbourhoods, and check if they properly light the path or not;
  • If possible, students should use a luxmeter to measure the amount of light around their houses.

Session 4

Estimated time: 50 minutes.

  • Students use Google Maps to identify the location of "good" and "bad" lighting examples they previously identified;
  • Students learn about the brightness of the stars and the apparent magnitude system;
  • Students learn how to use Stellarium.

 

Stellarium, a free planetarium software, in its 0.18.0 version.

Stellarium, a free planetarium software, in its 0.18.0 version.

Description

In the Imagine phase, the teacher will orient students to propose improvements to the lighting systems used in public sites (such as streets, side walks, parking lots, gardens, parks, sports fields, etc.), their school, and homes. The teacher should promote sessions with experts on the matter, so that students will have the opportunity to increase their knowledge and ask pertinent questions about the ideas they are developing. Examples of stakeholders are members of the local governmentarchitects, and engineers/technicians specialised in lighting systems. Students can also interview their family members and neighbours, to get their impressions on the topic, or to conduct a survey among them and their colleagues at school. A record must be kept of all the persons interviewed, with their names, professions, departments, and positions. Whenever possible, the sessions will be recorded in video or audio, and photographs should be taken of the people involved.

Interview

As always, debate and sharing of knowledge should be fostered in the classroom, and answers must not be given immediately.

This phase will be typically carried out in the classroom, during three sessions of 50 minutes each (this may vary, in case the interviews or sessions with experts are carried out).

Resources needed

Location

  • In the classroom.

Session 1

Estimated time: 50 minutes.

  • Students discuss in the class their findings about outdoor lighting in their way home and in their neighbourhoods;
  • Students search for acceptable and unacceptable lighting fixtures examples;
  • Students search for examples of luminaires that minimize glare, reduce light trespass, and don’t pollute the night sky.

Session 2

Estimated time: 50 minutes.

  • Students observe the impact of different types of outdoor lighting systems on the number of visible stars observed with the naked eye, using the Need‐less Interactive ‐ Light Pollution Simulator web app.
  • Using Stellarium (or similar software), students simulate the night sky for that day at the place where they live, varying the level of light pollution so that the apparent magnitude limit is about 5;
  • Students will compare their simulations with the actual sky that night, at their neighbourhoods.

Session 3

Estimated time: 50 minutes.

  • Students find people with professions related to the theme: scientists (physicists, biologists, etc.), medical doctors, architects, civil engineers, interior designers, and so on and so forth;
  • If possible, students engage in collaborations with local research centres;
  • With the help of the teacher, students will invite experts for a talk at the school or at their working place, and will carry out interviews, taking the opportunity to ask all relevant questions to the project;
  • As soon as all interviews and sessions with experts have been concluded (the number of which should be decided by students, according to their needs), students will compile all the information they have gathered.

Description

In the Create phase, students will write a report with their findings and conclusions, and will prepare all the material to present their work to stakeholders and the community.

This phase will be carried out in the classroom, during two sessions of 50 minutes each.

Resources needed

Location

  • In the classroom.

Sessions 1 and 2

Estimated time: 50 + 50 minutes.

  • Students prepare a written communication, a poster, a presentation or a video to present their findings to the local policy makers and other stakeholders, and to suggest improvements in the outdoor lighting systems adopted in their neighbourhoods and cities.

Students in the classroom.

Credit: www.pomona.edu.

Description

In the Share phase, the teacher will help students to share all material they have created in the framework of this project in the Internet, via social media channels, blogs and/or a website. The teacher must also guide students to book meetings with the stakeholders in order to present their conclusions and to suggest improvements or alternatives to the places that were studied during the project. Science Café sessions in the school, auditoriums or local coffee shops, and exhibitions in commercial areas are also encouraged, where students will have the opportunity to discuss their ideas with the local community, and bring awareness about the global problem of light pollution.

If all the steps are executed, this phase will typically be carried out in the classroom and in public venues, during four sessions of about one hour each.

Resources needed

  • Computers with access to the Internet.

Location

  • In the classroom (to prepare the material);

  • In the Town Hall and/or City Council;

  • In the school, auditoriums or at local coffee shops (for the Science Cafés);

  • At a local research centre (for collaborations with professionals working on the theme of light pollution or related fields);

  • In the local commercial area (for exhibitions).

Session 1

Estimated time: 50 minutes.

  • Students will share their findings in the Internet (social mediablog or website).

Session 2

Estimated time: 50 minutes.

  • With the help of the teacher, students present their work to their school and local community, by organising an exhibition with their findings, promoting awareness to the problematic of light pollution in local commercial areas.

Session 3

Estimated time: 60 minutes.

  • The teacher and students will promote Science Café sessions in the local community in order to promote awareness and discussion about the theme of light pollution. In these sessions, students are the scientists.

Session 4

Estimated time: 50 minutes.

  • Students will attempt to book a meeting with their Town Hall president and/or the Mayor in order to present the results of their study;
  • Students meet policy makers and other stakeholders, and present their findings.

Science café session.

A Science Café session. Credit: https://rockvillesciencecenter.org.